When an insurer declares your vehicle a total loss, its settlement offer is based on its own estimate of your vehicle's actual cash value (ACV). Those valuations — usually generated by CCC One, Mitchell or Audatex — frequently miss your vehicle's exact trim, packages, mileage, condition and the real Metro Detroit retail market.
You do not have to accept it. Most Michigan auto policies include an appraisal clause that lets you dispute the amount of loss. Detroit Auto Appraisers provides the certified, independent appraisal and represents you through the entire process — for a $475 flat fee.
We represent your interests — not the insurance company.
We negotiate with the insurer's appraiser and go to an umpire if needed.
Court-defensible appraisal reports used with every Michigan carrier.
In Michigan, total loss disputes are almost always first-party disputes with your own insurer. Because of no-fault, the at-fault driver's liability for your vehicle damage is limited to the $3,000 mini-tort — so your collision or comprehensive coverage and your policy's appraisal clause are where the real value is recovered.
Michigan's Vehicle Code defines actual cash value as the retail dollar value of a vehicle determined by an objective evaluation using local market resources such as dealers or want ads, by an independent vehicle evaluation or appraisal service, or by a nationally recognized used-vehicle guide (MCL 257.12a). Retail value — not wholesale or auction value — is the benchmark.
For late-model vehicles, MCL 257.217c requires a salvage title when estimated repair costs are 75% or more (but less than 91%) of pre-damage actual cash value, and a scrap title at 91% or more. That branding threshold is not the same thing as the settlement amount — you are still entitled to the full pre-loss value of your vehicle.
Michigan also requires timely payment. Under MCL 500.2006, benefits not paid within 60 days after the insurer receives satisfactory proof of loss can carry 12% simple annual interest. Sales tax, title and registration fees have been the subject of Michigan class actions against insurers that left them out of total loss payments — we check every settlement for them.
Most Michigan policies let either party demand appraisal when you disagree on the amount of loss. Here is how it works:
You notify your insurer in writing that you are invoking the appraisal clause and name Detroit Auto Appraisers as your independent appraiser. We give you the letter.
We research the Metro Detroit retail market, verify your vehicle's exact build and condition, and produce a USPAP-compliant appraisal of true actual cash value.
We negotiate directly with the insurer's appraiser. If we cannot agree, a neutral umpire reviews both appraisals and an agreement of any two is binding. The umpire's fee is split per your policy.
You receive a revised settlement based on your vehicle's real value — often thousands more than the original offer.
Detroit-area vehicles face road salt, potholes and periodic flash flooding — as the Metro Detroit floods of 2021 showed. Insurers often use these facts to argue for condition deductions that are not supported by your vehicle's actual history. We document condition, maintenance and rust protection carefully so unsupported deductions do not survive the appraisal process.
Send us the insurer's valuation report for a free review. We will tell you whether an independent appraisal can recover more.